The AtlasMeasures
How cancer is tested
How a piece of a patient becomes a cancer diagnosis, and every point at which a parasite could be in that piece and never be named.
- What it is
- The chain from removed tissue to written diagnosis: fixation, grossing, processing, sectioning, staining, extra tests, report 1,2,3,4
- Fixative
- 10% formalin (a one-in-ten dilution of 37% stock), buffered to neutral: 3.7% formaldehyde in water 5,6
- Breast timing rule
- Into fixative within 1 hour; fixed for 6 to 72 hours 6
- Slices at the bench
- 4 mm apart in one laboratory's mastectomies 2
- Shrinkage, fresh to slide
- 11.4% in 34 kidney tumors 8
- Special stains on hand
- 20 to 25 in a typical surgical pathology laboratory 9
- Agreement among pathologists
- 96% for invasive breast cancer, 48% for atypia 10
- Reports later amended
- 0.33% at one academic center, 2021 to 2025 11
- Best parasite comparison
- Schistosome eggs in 49% by squash, 18% by sections, 3% by smear, same 228 women 12
- Pathogen sequencing on blocks
- Positive in 36.8% of 623 infectious-pathology samples; 9 parasites 13
- Eggs recorded in bladder cancers, Tanzania
- 25.2% of 481 routine reports over 10 years 14
- Missed-parasite rate in tumors
- Not measured in any consecutive series found
In brief
What it is
The chain of steps that turns tissue removed from a patient into a written cancer diagnosis: fixation in formalin, dissection at the bench, wax processing, slicing 4 to 5 micrometers thin, staining, and then antibody, chromosome and DNA tests where needed 1,3,6,7,15,16. Every step is standardized to show human tissue clearly and to classify a human tumor; antibody tests, for instance, must be validated for the one molecule each was chosen to find 3.
Why it matters
Season one asks whether the cancers attributed to parasites are the real number or only the number anyone has looked for, and testing, including this pipeline, is where the looking happens. The International Agency for Research on Cancer (IARC) bases its 2024 estimates of parasite-caused cancer mainly on how often infection is found in people who have the cancer 17. The pipeline answers its own questions well, with 96% agreement on invasive breast cancer 10, and it measurably misses small, sparse parasite material that a fuller look finds 12.
When it reads low
A negative report means the questions that were asked were answered no, in the tissue that reached the glass. Among 228 Tanzanian women, routine sections found schistosome eggs in 18%, where squashing the whole biopsy found them in 49% 12; and deeper cuts, stained with an extra antibody for cytokeratin, through sentinel lymph nodes already called negative found small hidden deposits in 15.9% of 3,887 patients, with a five-year survival difference of only 1.2 percentage points 18.
When it reads high
A positive report can also mislead. Parasitic lesions have been read as malignant glioma on a needle biopsy and as glandular cancer on an urgent intraoperative examination 19,20, and the most prominent claim of tumor-specific microbes in sequencing data was retracted after most of the microbes proved absent from the samples 21,22.
A report answers the questions it was asked of the tissue that reached the slide, and nothing more.
What a pathology report is
Almost every solid-tumor diagnosis is made on tissue that has traveled the same road. It is removed from the patient and fixed, which means soaked in a chemical that stops it decaying and locks its structure in place. It is then dehydrated, cleared (its alcohol replaced by a solvent that mixes with wax), soaked in molten paraffin wax, set in a wax block, sliced on a precision blade called a microtome, stained, and read under a light microscope 1. The two workhorse chemicals of that road, formaldehyde and xylene, are hazardous enough that engineers have built processors designed to do without them 1. Around the slide sits a growing ring of further tests: antibodies that stain one chosen molecule, chromosome studies, and DNA sequencing 3,15,16.
A pathology report is best understood as a set of answers to questions somebody chose in advance. Is this cancer, and what kind? How large is it, how far has it spread, are the cut edges of the removed tissue clear, and which drug targets does it carry? The College of American Pathologists (CAP), the specialty's professional body in the United States, defined the content of the checklists that now structure most American cancer resection reports 4,23, and its guidelines require every antibody test to be validated so that it measures 'the analyte of interest', the one molecule it was chosen to find 3. For the questions they were built to answer, the answers are good: 115 American pathologists reading single breast-biopsy slides agreed with an expert reference on 96% of invasive cancers 10.
This page follows a specimen through that chain and asks, at each step, how a parasite could be in the tissue and never appear in the report. The answers come in two strengths, and the page keeps them apart. Some failures are documented: a study measured them, or a published case shows one happening. Others are plausible: they follow from how a step works, but nobody has counted them. The counterweight belongs at the start as well. When parasites are present and someone looks, pathologists name them, from pinworms in removed appendices to a tapeworm cyst inside what imaging had shown only as a pancreatic mass 24,25.
In three sentences each
Sampling decides what can be seen
A 5-micrometer section from a centimeter of tissue is one two-thousandth of its thickness, by simple arithmetic. The measured consequences are large: sections caught about a third of the schistosome infections a squash preparation found 12, and a benign lesion was recorded nearly three times as often in gallbladders embedded whole as in a separate, routinely sampled series 26.
Every extra test is a named question
Antibody tests are validated for one chosen molecule each 3, the workup for a cancer of unknown origin runs as an algorithm of human markers 27, and gene panels report human alterations, finding at least one in 96% of 200 such tumors 16. A negative answer covers its own question only.
Recognition depends on familiarity
The parasites that form cysts in tissue are rarely encountered by pathologists and carry many look-alike pitfalls 28. Tapeworm-derived tumor cells were unrecognizable as tapeworm until a DNA test named them 29, and even molds that pathologists see often are confused by shape 7.
Chemistry harms molecules more than shapes
Formalin fragments and chemically damages DNA 30, and hydrochloric-acid or prolonged formic-acid decalcification causes false-negative antibody and DNA results 31, but worms and cysts remain identifiable in routinely fixed tissue 24,25. The documented losses for parasites are sampling and recognition, not dissolution.
The full history
The method's oldest parts predate the microscope itself. Hematoxylin, the blue dye that colors cell nuclei on nearly every diagnostic slide, comes from the logwood tree, which Spanish explorers found in the Yucatán in 1502; amateur microscopists first used it to stain cells in the mid-1800s, and it remains the most popular nuclear stain in histology, the microscopic study of tissue 32. Formalin entered anatomy and histology after Ferdinand Blum discovered its fixing effect by accident in 1893 33; he, Ferdinand Julius Cohn and others put formaldehyde solutions to work preserving soft tissue 34. Special stains that pick out microorganisms, scarring and abnormal deposits had been part of tissue diagnosis for nearly a hundred years by 2000 9.
Pathology also found the first parasite-cancer links. In 1911 A. R. Ferguson, professor of pathology in Cairo, reported from 40 autopsies a likely association between bladder cancer and the granulomas, inflammatory nodules, that schistosome eggs provoke 35. It also produced the field's most famous error. In 1926 Johannes Fibiger received the Nobel Prize for a 'Spiroptera carcinoma' said to be caused by a worm in rats 36; a 1952 re-examination set the worm against vitamin A deficiency in the rat forestomach 37, and a 2004 study of the Nobel archives calls it 'a wrong Nobel Prize' 38.
The twentieth century added tests that each ask about one named thing. In 1956 Tjio and Levan established that a human cell carries 46 chromosomes, and the published recollections of how it happened differ strikingly from one another 39. In 1974 Taylor and Mason showed that an enzyme-labeled antibody could find one specific protein, immunoglobulin, inside cells in formalin-fixed paraffin sections 40. In 1991 a team whose first author worked at a reagent company showed that heating slides in a microwave oven, to as much as 100 °C in metal salt solutions, improved staining for 39 of 52 antibodies, including in long-fixed tissue that had failed to stain by older methods 41. DNA sequencing came last. By 2017 one cancer center had sequenced the tumors of more than 10,000 patients with a clinical gene panel 42, and the same year brought standards for the software that interprets the sequence 43.
In the 1990s the profession measured itself in audits like these. A 1994 audit across 233 small hospitals found that 1.8% of the frozen-section diagnoses not deferred, the rapid answers given while the patient is still in surgery, disagreed with the final slides, most often because a tumor was underdiagnosed through block or tissue sampling error 44. At one referral hospital, second review of outside cases changed 1.4% of diagnoses enough to alter treatment or prognosis 45. Guidelines followed, admitting that up to 20% of estrogen- and progesterone-receptor tests worldwide might be wrong 46, and then setting out how every antibody test must be validated 3,47.
Eight reversals run through this history, and each came from someone measuring what routine practice had assumed. The human chromosome count proved to be 46, not the 48 accepted for more than 30 years 48. Fibiger's Nobel-winning worm cancer did not survive re-examination 37,38. Underfixation, not the long-feared overfixation, proved the bigger threat to antibody staining 49. Hidden metastases found by extra cuts and an extra stain proved to matter little to survival 18. A single biopsy proved not to represent a tumor's genetics 50. Molds named by shape proved, on DNA testing, sometimes to be other molds 7,51. A tapeworm proved able to grow like a cancer inside a person while looking nothing like a tapeworm on the slide 29. And the most prominent claim that tumors carry readable microbial signatures was withdrawn, with later reanalysis widening the correction 21,22,52.
1502Seen
Hematoxylin is found
Spanish explorers in the Yucatán find the logwood tree, source of hematoxylin; a vigorous trade in it as a fabric dye soon develops 32.Mid-1800sSeen
Hematoxylin meets the microscope
Amateur microscopists use hematoxylin to color cell structures; it becomes, and remains, histology's most popular nuclear stain 32.1893Explained
c. 1900Explained
Special stains
Chemical stains for microorganisms, scarring and deposits enter tissue diagnosis; by 2000 a laboratory keeps 20 to 25 of them 9.1911Seen
Eggs and bladder cancer at autopsy
Ferguson links bladder cancer to schistosome granulomas in 40 Cairo autopsies 35.1926Seen
A Nobel for a worm cancer
Fibiger is honored for a 'Spiroptera carcinoma' in rats 36.1952Overturned
1956Overturned
1974Explained
Antibodies on paraffin sections
Taylor and Mason use an enzyme-labeled antibody to find immunoglobulin, the protein of antibodies, inside cells in formalin-paraffin sections from 33 tumors of antibody-making plasma cells 40.1983Seen
Unidentified curved bacilli
Warren and Marshall report 'unidentified curved bacilli' on the stomach lining in active chronic gastritis 53; the organism is later named Helicobacter pylori.1991Explained
Antigen retrieval
Microwave heating of slides improves staining for 39 of 52 antibodies on formalin-fixed tissue; the first author lists a reagent company 41.1992Explained
Whipple's bacillus named
After 85 years associated with an organism nobody could grow or identify, the bacillus of Whipple's disease is named from DNA copied out of five patients' tissue with broad-range primers 54.1994Seen
Frozen sections audited
Of 18,532 frozen-section diagnoses, 859 are deferred; 1.8% of the rest disagree with the final slides, most often an underdiagnosed tumor missed through block or tissue sampling 44.1995–1996Seen
Second opinions measured
Mandatory review of 6,171 outside cases at one referral hospital changes 86 diagnoses (1.4%) in ways that matter for treatment or prognosis 45.2001Seen
Sections against the squash
In 228 Tanzanian women, eggs of the blood fluke Schistosoma haematobium are found in 49% by squashing cervical tissue flat, 18% by routine sections and 3% by smears 12.2002Overturned
Overfixation was the wrong worry
Prostate tissue fixed for days stains better for the cell-cycle protein p27 than tissue processed the same day; underfixation is the bigger problem 49.2008Seen
A virus found by subtraction
Sequencing Merkel cell carcinomas, a rare skin cancer, and subtracting everything human reveals a new polyomavirus, a member of a family of small DNA viruses, present in 8 of 10 tumors 55.2009Policy
Checklists across a province
A Canadian province rolls out CAP cancer checklists over three years, and report completeness rises 4.2010Policy
Up to 20% of receptor tests may be wrong
The breast guideline of CAP and the American Society of Clinical Oncology (ASCO) traces most receptor-testing errors to handling, thresholds and interpretation 46.2011Overturned
Deeper levels, small benefit
Within a randomized trial, deeper cuts through sentinel nodes, the first lymph nodes draining the tumor, already called negative, examined with routine and cytokeratin antibody stains, find hidden cancer in 15.9% of 3,887 patients, with a 1.2-point difference in five-year survival 18.2012Overturned
One biopsy is not the tumor
Multiregion sequencing of kidney cancers finds 63% to 69% of mutations undetectable in at least one region 50.2014Policy
Every antibody test validated
CAP's first evidence-based guideline on validating immunohistochemistry, built from 126 of 1,463 publications 3.2015Overturned
A tapeworm's cancer in a person
Tumor-like cells in a man with HIV, the human immunodeficiency virus,, unrecognizable as tapeworm on the slide, prove to be Hymenolepis nana by a DNA-copying test (PCR) aimed at all eukaryotes, the organisms whose cells have a nucleus 29.2016Overturned
Molds are not reliably named by shape
DNA testing of 102 archived specimens finds the mold Fusarium in five that histology had called Aspergillus infection 7.2017Policy
Standards for sequencing software
The Association for Molecular Pathology (AMP) and CAP issue 17 recommendations for validating the pipelines that turn raw sequence into reported variants 43.2020Seen
A cancer microbiome claimed
A Nature paper reports microbial signatures across 18,116 tissue and blood sequencing samples from patients with 33 cancer types and proposes a blood test built on them 56.2023Overturned
Most of those microbes were not there
Reanalysis finds most reported microbes absent from the samples and more than a dozen follow-up studies likely invalid 21.2024Overturned
Retraction
Nature retracts the 2020 cancer-microbiome paper 22.2024Policy
Antibody validation updated
CAP's update adds rules for new scoring systems and for cytology specimens 47.2025Overturned
The correction widens
Reanalysis of all 5,734 TCGA whole genomes finds far less microbial content than reported 52.2025Seen
Pathogen sequencing in routine use
A Swiss university hospital reports 623 archived infectious-pathology samples sequenced for any DNA pathogen; 9 positives are parasites 13.2026Seen
Counting what was looked for
The International Agency for Research on Cancer (IARC) attributes 5,900 bladder and 3,800 bile-duct cancers in 2024 to parasites, estimated mainly from infection found in people with cancer 17.2026Seen
Sequencing names more molds
On 111 archived fungal specimens, metagenomic sequencing names the species in 81.1%, against 50.5% to 64.9% for two targeted DNA tests, and catches two rare fungi misdiagnosed as Aspergillus 51.
The journey of a specimen, step by step
The first choice is how much of the patient to take. A resection removes an organ or part of one. A biopsy takes a sample: by forceps through an endoscope, by a hollow core needle, or by freezing a piece onto a probe, which is called cryobiopsy. Cytology collects loose cells by fine-needle suction, brushing or drained fluid, and gives up the tissue's architecture. Quantity changes answers. In 300 early breast cancers, the grade on core biopsy, a score of how abnormal the cells look, matched the removed tumor in 73% overall, and in 83% when the cores totaled at least 50 mm against 68% when they did not, an association across cases rather than a trial 57. Across 132,352 American biopsies of the duodenum, the first part of the small intestine, the recommended four or more pieces arrived in only 35%, and celiac disease, an immune reaction to gluten that damages the intestinal lining, was newly diagnosed in 1.8% of those against 0.7% of the rest, an association in retrospective data 58.
Once tissue loses its blood supply, its cells keep working and begin digesting themselves until fixative reaches them. Warm ischemia time is the stretch while the tissue is still in the body with its blood supply clamped; cold ischemia time runs from removal to fixative. The breast-cancer guidelines of the American Society of Clinical Oncology (ASCO) and CAP ask for fixative within one hour and fixation for 6 to 72 hours 6. In 277 Japanese breast operations in 2018 and 2019, the median warm ischemia was 23 minutes, cold ischemia 37 minutes and fixation 43 hours, and 91.7% of cases met the guideline for cold ischemia and 94.9% for fixation time 59. Practice elsewhere is rougher: in an earlier retrospective audit of 64 breast specimens at one Cameroonian laboratory, restated in a 2026 study there, 85.9% underwent what the authors call prolonged fixation, with mastectomies left in formalin for up to 147 hours, largely because specimens accumulated over weekends and holidays 6. Some molecules do not wait at all: in 93 breast cancers, several signaling proteins carrying phosphate tags, the switches cells use to pass on messages, lost staining within one to two hours, and such proteins have been reported to degrade within 30 minutes 60.
The chemistry of fixation has its own page on formalin; the short version is this. Routine '10% formalin' is a one-in-ten dilution of a stock solution that is itself about 37% formaldehyde, so it holds 3.7% formaldehyde in water with about 1% methanol, and almost all of that formaldehyde exists as methylene glycol, a hydrated and less reactive form, so formalin soaks in quickly but fixes slowly: the first cross-links form over 24 to 48 hours, and fully stable ones may take about 30 days 5. Cross-linking means welding neighboring molecules together with small carbon bridges, which preserves shape and damages molecules. Prostate tissue fixed for a day or more stained more reliably than tissue rushed through the same day 49. Bone needs decalcification, the removal of calcium so a blade can cut it: hydrochloric acid and long formic-acid soaks caused false-negative antibody and DNA results in 35 samples, while EDTA (ethylenediaminetetraacetic acid), a chemical that gently pulls calcium out, did not 31.
Grossing is the bench step in which a pathologist or a pathologists' assistant describes the specimen by eye, slices it, and chooses which pieces go into cassettes, the small plastic cages that carry tissue through processing. One laboratory chills mastectomies to −80 °C for 20 minutes so that they can be sliced evenly at 4-mm intervals 2. Only the chosen pieces are ever seen under a microscope. How much that choice matters can be measured wherever someone has embedded everything: a benign gallbladder lesion called adenomyoma appeared in 9.3% of 203 gallbladders submitted whole, but in only 3.3% of a separate series of 2,347 routinely sampled ones, a comparison between two groups of patients rather than a test on the same organs 26. How much is submitted is set by rules, and the rules are under pressure. When a hysterectomy follows a cone biopsy of the cervix, protocol calls for the entire cervix to be submitted, an average of 16 blocks per case, with a range of 4 to 41; a 2025 study proposed cutting this to one representative section per quadrant, saving about two to six hours of laboratory work per case 61. Less tissue submitted means fewer chances to come across anything nobody was looking for.
Processing replaces the water in tissue with wax so it can be sliced thin. The cassettes pass through graded alcohols, a series of increasingly pure ethanol baths that draw water out, then xylene, a solvent that displaces the alcohol and mixes with wax, then molten paraffin, and the tissue is finally embedded in a wax block 1,6. Embedding sets the tissue's orientation in the block, and so which face the blade will cut; thin, narrow pieces curl during processing and are hard to orient, so they can end up cut at a slant 62. The chemicals are more forgiving of time than their reputation suggests: in tissue fixed for three to five weeks, an extra 24 hours in absolute ethanol, xylene, molten paraffin or on a heated embedding station caused no visible change in structure or routine staining, and most antibody tests were preserved 63. The tissue shrinks on the way: 34 kidney tumors measured 11.4% smaller on the slide than when fresh, enough to move two of them into a lower size stage 8. The DNA is damaged as well: DNA extracted from formalin-fixed tissue is fragmented and carries chemical lesions that can masquerade as mutations 30. It remains usable for targeted tests: one laboratory amplified 300- to 400-base-pair stretches from formalin-fixed, paraffin-embedded tissue, the standard archival state known as FFPE, and judged the DNA suitable for molecular testing 2, a base pair being one rung of the DNA ladder.
The block is sliced on the microtome into ribbons 4 to 5 micrometers thick, a micrometer being a thousandth of a millimeter, and each ribbon is floated onto a glass slide 6,7. The slide is stained with hematoxylin and eosin, H&E, the blue-and-pink pair: eosin is the pink dye that colors proteins in the cell body and the surrounding tissue. The hematoxylin acts as hemalum, a red complex of aluminum and hematein, the oxidized form of hematoxylin, that is drawn electrostatically to the phosphate backbone of DNA and turns blue and insoluble when the slide is rinsed at a pH of 5.5 to 8.5, near neutral on the 0-to-14 scale of acidity 64. Everything else, from special stains to antibodies to sequencing, is called ancillary, meaning supplementary to that first look 27.
| Step | What happens | A real number | What a parasite could lose here |
|---|---|---|---|
| Collection | Resection, biopsy or cytology | Core grade matched the tumor in 73% of 300 breast cancers 57 | Lying outside the piece taken (documented 65) |
| Transport | Tissue waits for fixative | Median cold ischemia 37 minutes in 277 operations 59 | Molecules degrade 60; loss of whole organisms not measured |
| Fixation | Formalin cross-links protein | First cross-links over 24 to 48 hours 5 | DNA and some proteins; acid decalcification gives false negatives 31 |
| Grossing | Slicing and choosing pieces | Slices 4 mm apart in one laboratory's mastectomies 2 | Lying in tissue never submitted (documented for other lesions 26) |
| Processing | Alcohols, xylene, paraffin | 11.4% shrinkage, fresh to slide 8 | True size; DNA fragmented and chemically damaged 30 |
| Sectioning | Ribbons 4 to 5 micrometers thick | Sections used for DNA work are 4 to 5 micrometers 7 | Lying between planes (documented: 18% against 49% 12) |
| Staining and reading | H&E, then ancillary tests | 96% agreement on invasive breast cancer 10 | Not being recognized (documented 28,29) |
| Report | Checklist of required items | Checklists raised completeness in 32 of 33 studies 66 | No item to record it in (plausible; not measured) |
The right-hand column marks what has been documented and what is only plausible.
The words, defined
- Fixation
- Soaking tissue in a chemical, almost always formalin, that stops decay and locks structure in place.
- Cold ischemia time
- The minutes or hours between removing tissue and getting it into fixative.
- Warm ischemia time
- The time tissue spends in the body with its blood supply already clamped.
- Cross-link
- A small chemical bridge formalin builds between neighboring molecules.
- Decalcification
- Removing calcium from bone or calcified tissue so it can be sliced.
- Grossing
- Describing, slicing and choosing pieces of a specimen at the bench.
- Cassette
- A small plastic cage that carries a piece of tissue through processing.
- FFPE
- Formalin-fixed, paraffin-embedded: the standard archival form of diagnostic tissue.
- Microtome
- A precision blade that slices the wax block into thin ribbons.
- H&E
- Hematoxylin and eosin, the blue-and-pink stain used on nearly every diagnostic slide.
How much of a tumor reaches a slide
The arithmetic is simple, and it is the heart of the matter. A single section 5 micrometers thick, cut from a piece of tissue a centimeter thick, contains one two-thousandth of that thickness, or 0.05%. From a 3-mm piece in a cassette, one section is about one six-hundredth. A core from a 14-gauge needle is about 1 mm across and 5 to 15 mm long 6; a 15-mm core from a tumor 2 cm across holds about 0.28% of the tumor's volume, and one section along that core holds about one part in 56,000 of the tumor. These figures are this page's arithmetic from published dimensions, not measurements, and real practice cuts several sections from several blocks. They make one point: a slide is a sample of a sample of a sample.
Geometry decides whether something small is caught. An object 100 micrometers across, sitting at a random depth in a 3-mm piece, is crossed by any one section plane with a probability of about 100 in 3,000, roughly 3%, again by arithmetic, for a single object; many eggs scattered through a piece raise the odds, which is why sections succeeded more often when eggs were dense 12. That is why pathologists cut deeper 'levels' when the first slide is unrevealing, and the yield is real. In a randomized breast-cancer trial, sentinel lymph nodes, the first nodes draining a tumor, that had been reported negative were re-cut at two widely spaced deeper levels and stained both routinely and with an antibody for cytokeratin. Hidden metastases appeared in 15.9% of 3,887 patients, but the first look had been designed only to catch deposits larger than 2 mm, and five-year survival differed by just 1.2 percentage points 18. In the audit of 18,532 frozen sections, the commonest disagreement was an underdiagnosed tumor, usually through block or tissue sampling, and the authors advised deeper cuts or more tissue when a first section is negative or unrevealing 44.
The best measurement of this loss for a parasite is old, small and unambiguous. In 228 women living where Schistosoma haematobium is common in Tanzania, eggs in cervical tissue were found in 112 (49%) by the quantitative compressed biopsy technique, which squashes the fresh piece flat between glass and looks through all of it; in 40 (18%) by routine histological sections; and in 6 (3%) by cervical smears 12. Relative to the squash, sections found about 36% of the positive women and smears about 5%, by this page's arithmetic from the published counts. Sections succeeded more often when eggs were dense, which is what the geometry predicts 12.
Tumors are not uniform, which compounds the problem. Sequencing several regions of the same kidney cancers found that 63% to 69% of all mutations could not be detected in every region 50. A benign gallbladder lesion was recorded in 9.3% of gallbladders embedded whole against 3.3% of a separate, routinely sampled series, a comparison between two groups of patients rather than a test on the same organs 26. The pattern across these studies is consistent: for small lesions and whole organisms the documented losses come from sampling, and they fall hardest on whatever is small, sparse or unevenly spread 12,18,26; no study found has measured a comparable loss from chemistry.
| Starting tissue | What is examined | Fraction | Dimensions from |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 cm of tissue | One 5-micrometer section | 0.05% (1 in 2,000) | Section thickness 6 |
| A 3-mm piece in a cassette | One 5-micrometer section | About 0.17% (1 in 600) | Section thickness 6 |
| The same piece | Three sections: the first and two deeper levels | 0.5% | Two extra levels, as in 18 |
| A tumor 2 cm across | One 14-gauge core, 1 mm by 15 mm | About 0.28% | Core size 6 |
| The same tumor | One 5-micrometer section along that core | About 1 in 56,000 | Core size and section thickness 6 |
| A 100-micrometer object at random depth in a 3-mm piece | One section plane | About a 3% chance of being cut | Arithmetic only |
Every fraction is this page's arithmetic, not a measured finding. Real practice cuts several blocks and levels; the point is the order of magnitude.
The words, defined
- Level
- A further section cut deeper into the same block, showing a plane the first slide did not.
- Sentinel lymph node
- The first lymph node draining a tumor, removed to check whether cancer has spread.
- Metastasis
- A deposit of cancer that has spread from where it started.
- Compressed biopsy technique
- Squashing fresh tissue flat between glass and examining all of it, instead of a thin slice.
Tests that answer only the question asked
Everything after H&E is a question about a named thing. An antibody stain asks whether one chosen protein is present; a gene panel asks whether chosen stretches of human DNA are altered; a chromosome study asks whether the human chromosomes are the right number and shape. The rules that govern these tests make the point themselves. CAP requires each antibody test to be validated with cases chosen so that it 'accurately measures the analyte of interest' in that laboratory's own specimens 3, and the 2024 update extends those rules to newer scoring systems and to cytology 47. A negative result is therefore an answer to its own question and to nothing else.
That design is a strength as well as a limit. The workup for a metastatic cancer with no obvious origin runs as an algorithm that begins with two keratins, structural proteins of lining cells, called CK7 and CK20, and branches to organ-specific antibodies 27. Even so, immunohistochemistry, the antibody method, pins a single tissue of origin in only 10.8% to 51% of these cancers of unknown primary 67. Gene panels almost always find at least one change in the tumor's own DNA: a commercial panel run on 200 such tumors reported at least one alteration in 192 (96%), in a study whose 17 authors all listed Foundation Medicine, the company that sells it 16. Every one of these questions is about a human molecule 16,27.
Special stains
Chemical stains that color one class of material, part of tissue diagnosis for about a century, with 20 to 25 kept in a typical surgical pathology laboratory 9.
They include the acid-fast stain for the tuberculosis bacillus, trichrome for scarring, silver for basement membranes, the thin sheets beneath lining cells, Prussian blue for iron and Congo red for amyloid, an abnormal protein deposit, with newer applications for microsporidia, spore-forming organisms that live inside cells and are now classified with the fungi, and for Helicobacter pylori 9.
Their sensitivity can be poor. In 100 lung-wash samples, in a study of colonization, where organisms are present in small numbers without disease, three classic stains found Pneumocystis jirovecii, a fungus that infects people with weakened immunity, in none, while an antibody test found it in 13 and a DNA test in 16 68.
Immunohistochemistry
An antibody chosen to bind one protein is laid on the section and made visible with a colored product, a method shown on formalin-paraffin tissue in 1974 40.
Formalin's cross-links hide many targets, and heating the slide, called antigen retrieval, unmasks them; in 1991 it improved staining for 39 of 52 antibodies 41. Each test must be validated for its target before it touches patient tissue 3.
Antibodies against parasites exist and work on archived tissue when someone orders them: a laboratory-made antibody called Em2G11 labels Echinococcus multilocularis, a tapeworm whose larval stage invades the liver, in fixed tissue 69, and antibody staining labeled the tapeworm cells in the Hymenolepis case once DNA had named them 29.
DNA sequencing
Next-generation sequencing reads millions of short DNA fragments at once; each fragment, called a read, is matched against a human reference genome, a standard map of human DNA such as the version known as GRCh38 70.
Clinical laboratories are advised to validate the software that does this matching and reports variants under 17 consensus recommendations from the Association for Molecular Pathology (AMP) and CAP, written because laboratories varied widely in how they did it 43. What happens to reads that match nothing human has been described for at least one clinical laboratory. At Washington University, reads from a 151-gene clinical cancer panel that did not map to the human genome had been 'previously discarded'. When researchers recovered them from 21 consecutive high-grade gliomas, those reads made up 1.9% of the total, about 38,000 per case, and held Epstein-Barr virus sequence in 5 cases; none of the 4 cases with material for in situ hybridization, a stain that marks viral genetic material in the tissue section itself, was positive 71. No survey of what accredited laboratories in general do with such reads was found.
Research pipelines show that non-human reads can be informative when someone looks: subtracting human sequence from Merkel cell carcinomas, a rare skin cancer, revealed a new virus in 8 of 10 tumors 55, and a study of 2,658 cancers found viral sequence in 382 genomes 72. They also show the danger. In tumor genomes non-human reads are 'a small minority', a recent cleanup method used three human reference genomes to remove the remaining human reads 70, and the most prominent microbial claim was retracted 21,22.
The correction has since widened. A 2025 reanalysis of all 5,734 whole-genome samples in The Cancer Genome Atlas (TCGA), the largest public archive of tumor sequence, found microbial presence far smaller than earlier reports and many reported species possibly absent altogether 52. That does not make tumors sterile. Bacteria have been seen inside tumor and immune cells across seven cancer types 73, and a 2024 analysis of 4,160 metastatic tumor biopsies tied Fusobacterium to resistance to immunotherapy in lung cancer 74. These analyses concern bacteria, viruses, archaea and fungi; their abstracts do not report parasites.
Chromosome studies
A karyotype is a picture of a cell's chromosomes taken while the cell divides; a normal human cell has 46 39.
In blood cancers, chromosome work remains standard: a complete survey of structural changes there still combines karyotyping, FISH (fluorescent probes that light up chosen chromosome regions) and DNA arrays, chips that measure gained or lost stretches of DNA 75.
A karyotype needs living, dividing cells, so it can be made only from fresh tissue sent before fixation; that is routine for blood cancers, while solid tumors are mostly studied on fixed tissue, with FISH and DNA tests instead. In one gene-fusion panel study of 329 specimens, the 214 consecutive clinical cases comprised 73 leukemia and lymphoma specimens and 141 formalin-fixed solid tumors, with conventional karyotyping among the comparison tests 15.
The words, defined
- Immunohistochemistry
- Staining a section with an antibody that binds one chosen protein, so that protein shows up in color.
- Analyte
- The specific substance a test is designed to measure.
- Antigen retrieval
- Heating or treating a slide to undo enough formalin cross-links that antibodies can bind again.
- Next-generation sequencing
- Reading the letters of millions of DNA fragments at once.
- Read
- One short stretch of sequenced DNA.
- Reference genome
- A standard assembled map of human DNA that reads are matched against.
- Karyotype
- A picture of a dividing cell's chromosomes, used to count them and check their shape.
- FISH
- Fluorescence in situ hybridization: glowing DNA probes that mark chosen chromosome regions.
- Cancer of unknown primary
- A cancer that has spread where no starting site can be found.
- H&E histologyHematoxylin and eosin on a 4- to 5-micrometer section: the standard first slide 6,7,64.On essentially every specimen.96% agreement with experts for invasive breast cancer, 48% for atypia 10.Anything outside the plane cut: eggs were found in 18% of women by sections against 49% by squash 12.
- Special stains for organismsChemical stains such as the acid-fast stain, which colors the waxy-walled bacteria of tuberculosis, and silver stains, used among other things for fungi 9,68; a laboratory keeps 20 to 25 special stains 9.When someone suspects an infection.Poor for small numbers of organisms: in 100 lung washes from a study of colonization, three classic stains found Pneumocystis in none, an antibody test in 13 and a DNA test in 16 68.Organisms nobody asked about, since each stain must be requested.
- ImmunohistochemistryAn antibody against one chosen protein, validated for that target 3,47.Tumor type, origin and drug targets.Names a single tissue of origin in 10.8% to 51% of cancers of unknown primary 67; up to 20% of receptor tests may be inaccurate 46.Every protein not on the panel. Antibodies against parasites, such as the laboratory-made Em2G11 for Echinococcus multilocularis, exist in specialist laboratories and must be specifically requested 69.
- Tumor gene panel (next-generation sequencing)Reads DNA fragments and matches them to the human reference genome 43,70.Choosing targeted therapy.At least one human alteration in 192 of 200 cancers of unknown primary, in a manufacturer-authored study 16.One clinical laboratory discarded the reads that did not match the human genome until researchers mined them, finding 1.9% non-human 71; no survey across laboratories was found, and formalin fragments and damages DNA 30.
- Metagenomic sequencing of the block (mNGS)Sequences all DNA in an archived sample and looks for any DNA pathogen 13.Infectious pathology cases, not routine tumors.A plausible pathogen in 36.8% of 623 samples, 9 of them parasites; 9.6% uninterpretable 13.Older blocks: a parasite-specific DNA-copying test (PCR) worked in all 6 blocks under six years old but in only 3 of the 9 older ones 69; no comparable figure was found for mNGS.
What the report is built to say, and how it is checked
Cancer reports have moved from free narrative to synoptic format, a fixed checklist of required items filled in for every case. CAP defined the scientifically validated content of those checklists, and when one Canadian province put them into use over three years, both the use of synoptic reports and their completeness rose 4. A systematic review of 33 studies found that all but one recorded more complete reports after the change, with gains in items such as resection margins, the cut edges of the removed tissue, and invasion of blood vessels, lymphatic channels and nerves 66. Adoption is incomplete. Across the US Department of Veterans Affairs, the largest integrated health system in the country, 48% of 1,618 cancer pathology reports from 2019 to 2021 were synoptic: 77% of resections but only 19% of biopsies 23.
A checklist records what it asks for. Its items, in the studies reviewed, describe the human tumor: its type, size, location, depth of invasion, margins and lymph nodes 66. Each CAP cancer protocol lists required, or core, data elements, which the protocol authors describe as 'the minimum set of evidence-based, clinically actionable parameters' for diagnosis, prognosis and treatment 76; the protocols have guided American cancer reporting for more than 35 years 77. Required items can reach beyond the tumor when a finding changes care: since 2010 the kidney-cancer protocol has required evaluation of the non-cancerous kidney 78. What a report asks also follows treatment: once a drug became available for breast cancers with low HER2 protein, the 2023 HER2 update made the line between 'IHC 0' and '1+' newly important to report 79. Cancer registries inherit the tumor's shape. IARC's 2024 estimates take national counts by anatomical site and, for subtypes such as squamous cell carcinoma of the bladder, a cancer of flat lining cells, by the tumor-type codes of the international oncology classification, ICD-O-3; the share caused by an infection is then estimated mainly from the prevalence of that infection measured in people with the cancer 17. Registries record the tumor, not the organism; the infection share is supplied by studies that tested people with the cancer, so it can reflect only the organisms somebody tested for 17. No required item this page found asks for a coexisting parasite. Whether the optional findings lists in the current bladder and intrahepatic bile duct protocols, in their June 2025 versions, name schistosomiasis or liver flukes still has to be checked in the protocol documents, which could not be opened for this review.
Quality assurance in pathology is serious, and it is measured. Agreement depends sharply on the question: on single breast-biopsy slides, 115 pathologists matched an expert reference on 96% of invasive cancers but only 48% of atypia, the gray zone before cancer, and the three experts agreed unanimously among themselves only 75% of the time 10. Mandatory review of outside cases at one referral hospital changed 1.4% of diagnoses in a way that mattered for treatment or prognosis 45. At one large academic center, 0.33% of final reports were amended between 2021 and 2025, within the benchmarks of CAP's quality programs 11. And for molecules every laboratory hunts deliberately, the 2010 guideline panel accepted that up to 20% of receptor tests worldwide might be wrong 46; the 2020 update added an 'ER Low Positive' reporting category for tumors with 1% to 10% of cells staining 80.
Every one of these checks compares pathologists with each other, or tests with each other, on questions already being asked 10,45. None of them can measure how often something is missed that no one is looking for, except by going back and asking: an unasked question has no second reader. The few measurements that exist were made that way, by re-testing archived tissue for a parasite 81,82 or by mining sequence that had been discarded 71. That limit is a matter of design rather than of evidence, and it is why this page could find no measurement of how often parasite material in tumor specimens goes unreported.
The words, defined
- Synoptic report
- A pathology report built from a fixed checklist of required items.
- Margin
- The cut edge of removed tissue; a clear margin means no tumor reaches it.
- Atypia
- Cells that look abnormal but fall short of cancer.
- Amended report
- A final report corrected after it was issued.
- ICD-O-3
- The international coding system for the site and microscopic type of a tumor.
Every way a parasite can be missed
Put the steps together and there are six distinct ways a parasite can be in a tumor specimen and absent from the report. They differ in evidence. Two are documented directly for parasites: the organism was not sampled, or it was not recognized. One is documented for molecules but not for organisms: damage in processing. Two are documented outside the tumor question: the specific test was never ordered, documented in infectious pathology, and sequence reads were set aside, documented in one clinical sequencing laboratory 71. One is plausible and unmeasured: the organism was seen but not recorded, because the report had no place for it. The table keeps them apart; the paragraphs give the evidence.
Failure to sample is the best documented. Routine sections found schistosome eggs in 40 women where the squash found them in 112, about a third as many 12. A lung fluke's eggs were found on cryobiopsy in a patient who had both cryobiopsy and the smaller forceps biopsy, and the authors argue the larger specimen gives a better chance of containing eggs 65; surgeons describing a lung fluke in the abdomen noted in general that eggs in biopsy specimens may be difficult to detect 'due to an insufficient amount' 83. Failure to recognize is documented case by case. Tapeworm-derived tumor cells were 'unrecognizable as tapeworm tissue' until a DNA test named them 29; a brain cysticercus, the larval cyst of the pork tapeworm, was diagnosed as malignant glioma, a brain cancer, on needle biopsy 19; and an urgent frozen section, read during the operation, that took lung fluke disease for glandular cancer led to a resection, after which the patient died of a pulmonary embolism, a blood clot in the lungs, on the second day after surgery 20. The pattern continues. In 2025, a frozen section of a bladder mass in a 10-year-old Sudanese immigrant in the United States was read as a rhabdoid malignancy, an aggressive childhood cancer; the permanent sections showed numerous schistosome eggs and no cancer 84. In northeastern Italy, five tonsil swellings that mimicked cancer between 2014 and 2024 proved to be leishmaniasis, an infection with a single-celled parasite, which was seen on histology in four and confirmed by PCR in all five 85.
Recognition fails for an understandable reason: pathologists rarely see these organisms. Organisms can sit on routine slides for decades before anyone names them. Whipple's disease had been associated for 85 years with a bacillus that no one could grow or identify, until DNA copied from five patients' tissue with broad-range primers named it Tropheryma whippelii in 1992 54. In 1983 Warren and Marshall reported 'unidentified curved bacilli' on the stomach lining in gastritis 53; that organism, Helicobacter pylori, is now credited with 760,000 cancers in 2024, more than any other infection 17. A 2025 review states that parasitic cysts and pseudocysts, cyst-like spaces without a true lining, are rarely encountered by pathologists, carry many look-alike pitfalls, and, when the diagnosis is difficult, should be reviewed by an infectious-disease pathologist or a parasitologist used to tissue sections 28. Even organisms pathologists see often can mislead by shape: DNA testing found a different mold, Fusarium, in five archived specimens that histology had called aspergillosis, infection with the mold Aspergillus 7. On 111 archived fungal specimens, metagenomic sequencing named the species in 81.1%, against 50.5% to 64.9% for two targeted DNA tests, and caught two rare fungi misdiagnosed as Aspergillus 51. A tapeworm larva in a man's hip was treated as cysticercosis, without effect, until sequencing the archived block named Spirometra mansoni, in a report coauthored by employees of a commercial laboratory 86.
Software now reads digitized slides, but it looks for what it was trained to find. A 2025 deep-learning tool trained to find Helicobacter pylori on scanned gastric biopsies scored 0.62 for the organisms themselves on the F1 scale, a 0-to-1 measure combining hits and false alarms 87, and another group noted that some scanned images lack the resolution to show the bacteria 88. This review found no published tool that screens tumor slides for parasites.
Failure to order the test is documented wherever someone went back and ordered it. A parasite-specific PCR on archived bowel specimens that showed only the tissue reaction to Angiostrongylus costaricensis, a roundworm that causes abdominal disease, found the worm's DNA in 4 of 20 81. Outside pathology, seropositive migrant women in the Barcelona area had attended a sexual and reproductive health unit a median of 41 times before schistosomiasis was diagnosed 89. Setting reads aside is documented in at least one clinical laboratory, where reads from a cancer gene panel that did not match the human genome had been 'previously discarded' 71. The published validation standards are written for detecting genomic alterations 43, research pipelines that do look for non-human reads must first strip out human sequence against several human references 70, and no survey across laboratories was found. In research data the opposite error is documented, in which microbial signals were reported that were not there 21.
The counter-evidence is just as real. When organisms are present and the task includes looking for them, they are found: in cervical cytology, Trichomonas vaginalis, a single-celled parasite, was identified in 10 of 11 positive samples on both preparations compared 90. Routine histology of 846 children's appendices identified pinworms in 12 and Taenia tapeworm in 2, although the paper's printed rate of 0.39% does not match its own counts 24. A pancreatic mass, removed along with the tail of the pancreas and the spleen, proved on histology to be a hydatid cyst, the larval stage of a tapeworm 25. The errors also run the other way. A brown pigment that unbuffered formalin forms with blood 'may simulate microorganisms', and fungi, fibers or fragments of another patient's tissue can contaminate a slide during processing 62. Formalin and wax do not routinely erase a worm, since worms and cysts are named in fixed tissue 24,25; the documented losses are a thin plane and an unfamiliar shape 12,28, although no study found has measured how recognizable fixed helminth material remains.
| Way it is missed | What happens | Best evidence | Strength |
|---|---|---|---|
| Not sampled | It lies in tissue never submitted, or between section planes | Sections 18% against squash 49% in the same 228 women 12; eggs found on cryobiopsy, the larger specimen 65 | Documented for parasites |
| Not recognized | It is on the slide but read as tumor, inflammation or debris | Tapeworm cells 'unrecognizable' 29; cysticercosis read as glioma 19 | Documented, case by case |
| Damaged in processing | Chemistry degrades its DNA or proteins | Acid decalcification false negatives 31; FFPE DNA fragmented and carrying sequence artifacts 30 | Documented for molecules; not measured for whole parasites |
| Never tested | The specific stain, antibody or PCR is never ordered | PCR positive in 4 of 20 bowel specimens with no worm seen 81 | Documented in infectious pathology; unmeasured in tumors |
| Reads set aside | Sequence that matches nothing human is not examined | Unmapped reads from one clinical cancer panel had been 'previously discarded' and made up 1.9% of reads 71; non-human reads 'a small minority' of tumor sequence 70 | Documented in one clinical laboratory; not surveyed across laboratories |
| Seen but not recorded | The checklist has no item for it | Checklist items describe the human tumor 66; required items are the 'minimum set of ... clinically actionable parameters' 76; where eggs are expected, reports do record them, in 25.2% of 481 bladder cancers 14 | Plausible outside endemic centers; unmeasured |
Documented means a study or a published case shows it happening. Plausible means it follows from how the step works, but nobody has counted it.
What is done when someone suspects an organism
When a pathologist or clinician does suspect a parasite, the tools are good and getting better. The first is expertise: the 2025 review recommends slide review by an infectious-disease pathologist or a parasitologist accustomed to tissue sections, completed where possible by a combined tissue-and-molecular diagnosis 28. The second is a targeted test. A PCR for Echinococcus based on its 12S ribosomal DNA, a gene for part of the parasite's protein-making machinery whose sequence differs between species, detected as few as 50 parasite cells per specimen and worked on archived blocks; of 15 blocks with living lesions of alveolar echinococcosis, the liver disease caused by that tapeworm's larva, 9 were positive, including all 6 stored for less than six years, and the authors recommend blocks under five years old 69. For the smallest particles of parasite material the antibody stain did better: 11 of 15 such samples were negative by PCR 69. A PCR for abdominal angiostrongyliasis had 55% sensitivity, meaning it caught 55% of true cases, and 100% specificity, meaning it raised no false alarms in the comparison specimens 81.
The broadest tool is unbiased sequencing of all the DNA in a block, called metagenomic next-generation sequencing, or mNGS. At University Hospital Basel, between November 2021 and April 2025, 623 archived tissue samples were tested this way as part of routine infectious-disease pathology: 229 (36.8%) yielded at least one plausible pathogen, 334 (53.6%) were negative, and 60 (9.6%) could not be interpreted because of quality failures or suspected contamination; 9 of the positive results were parasites 13. That is a working clinical service, and it was applied to infectious-pathology cases rather than to unselected tumor resections 13. On archived surgical specimens showing granulomas, the same approach detected all 31 confirmed mycobacterial infections, with 88% specificity, and found all 19 tuberculosis cases against 47% for the standard molecular test on the same blocks 91.
Some of the most effective measures are not laboratory tests at all. For eggs in tissue, looking through a whole squashed fragment found nearly three times as many infections as sections did 12, and a larger biopsy found eggs, its authors argue because it was larger 65. History changes the question too. The child whose cysticercosis was read as glioma had been born in Korea, which the team did not know at the time 19, and the surgeons who found a lung fluke in the abdomen urged clinicians to take a thorough history and to remember that an abdominal mass may be a parasite 83. A test that is never ordered finds nothing.
The words, defined
- PCR
- Polymerase chain reaction: copying one chosen stretch of DNA until it can be detected.
- Sensitivity
- The share of true cases a test catches.
- Specificity
- The share of true negatives a test correctly calls negative.
- mNGS
- Metagenomic next-generation sequencing: reading all the DNA in a sample to look for any organism.
What was believed and is not
The first eight cards below are reversals inside pathology and its laboratories, each found by someone who measured what routine practice had assumed. The last two concern ideas that come up whenever parasites and cancer are discussed together. One of them, the show's own working idea that every test in a tumor workup was built for a different question than a parasite raises, holds up. The other, that formalin and paraffin make parasites invisible, does not, at least as it is usually stated.
The reversals share a shape. In each, routine practice had stopped at the first plausible answer: one fixation time, one biopsy, one plane through a lymph node, one reading of a shape, one pass of software over sequence data. Each correction came from doing more than the routine did: a count redone with better preparations 48, a worm set against a vitamin deficiency in the same organ 37, more days in formalin 49, more regions sequenced 50, more levels cut and an extra stain 18, a DNA test where the slide was ambiguous 7,29,51, a fresh analysis of someone else's reads 21. That is the same move this page argues for with parasites, and it carries the same warning, because looking harder finds more, and only some of what it finds turns out to matter 18.
A worm was proved to cause cancer
Johannes Fibiger received the 1926 Nobel Prize for a 'Spiroptera carcinoma' said to be caused by a worm in rats 36. A 1952 re-examination set the worm against vitamin A deficiency in the rat forestomach 37, and a 2004 study of the Nobel archives calls the prize a wrong one 38. It is this field's own warning about reading cause into a parasite found beside a tumor.
WhenCorrected 1952
A human cell carries 48 chromosomes
The number was taken to be 48 for more than 30 years, until Tjio and Levan counted 46 in Lund in 1955 and 1956; the history of the correction notes that the accepted figure had shaped how earlier preparations were read 48.
WhenCorrected 1956
Overfixation is the main threat to antibody staining
Measured on 564 prostate tissue cores fixed from zero to eight days, the larger problem was underfixation: staining for the protein p27 improved with a day or more in formalin and was still excellent at eight days 49. The breast guidelines now set both a floor and a ceiling, 6 to 72 hours 6.
WhenCorrected 2002
Every hidden metastasis must be hunted down
Deeper cuts through 'negative' sentinel nodes, stained routinely and with an antibody for cytokeratin, found hidden cancer in 15.9% of 3,887 patients, and it predicted a slightly worse outcome, but five-year survival differed by 1.2 percentage points and the trial found no clinical benefit in routine extra examination 18. Looking harder finds more; whether that helps the patient is a separate question.
WhenCorrected 2011
One biopsy shows a tumor's genetics
In kidney cancers sampled in several places, 63% to 69% of mutations were undetectable in at least one region, and signatures of good and poor prognosis sat in different regions of the same tumor 50. The finding has since been extended to a parasite-linked cancer: multiregion sequencing of 52 samples from 13 liver-fluke-associated cholangiocarcinomas found marked differences between regions of the same tumor 92.
WhenCorrected 2012
A tumor growing in a person is always made of human cells
Tapeworms were not known to develop cancers. In 2015, tumor-like cells in a man with HIV, the human immunodeficiency virus, proved to be Hymenolepis nana, the dwarf tapeworm, carrying genomic changes like those described in cancer 29. It remains a single case.
WhenCorrected 2015
A mold can be named by its shape on the slide
DNA testing of 102 archived specimens found Fusarium in five that histology had called Aspergillus infection 7. On 111 archived specimens, metagenomic sequencing named the species in 81.1% against 50.5% to 64.9% for two targeted DNA tests, and caught two rare fungi that had been misdiagnosed as Aspergillus 51.
WhenCorrected 2016, widened 2026
Tumor sequencing data reveal cancer-specific microbes
A 2020 Nature paper said so, from 18,116 samples, and one coauthor listed a commercial genomics affiliation 56. Reanalysis found most of the reported microbes were not present in the samples at all 21, and the paper was retracted in 2024 22.
WhenRetracted 2024
Every test in a tumor workup was designed for a different question than a parasite raises
Confirmed. The antibody guidelines validate each test for its chosen analyte 3, the checklists record features of the human tumor 66, and the gene panels report human alterations 16. The one caveat is that designed for a different question is not the same as blind: H&E can show a worm when the plane passes through one 24, though recognition is not guaranteed 19,29.
WhenHolds, with one caveat
Formalin and paraffin make parasites invisible
Not as stated. Worms and cysts are identified in routinely fixed tissue, from children's appendices to a resected pancreatic mass 24,25, and schistosome eggs were seen in routine sections from 18% of women 12. What processing damages is DNA 30 and, with acid decalcification, antibody and DNA results 31; what hides a parasite is the thinness of the plane and the rarity of the sight.
WhenNot supported
What is still unknown
The central number does not exist. No study that this page could find has taken a consecutive series of tumor resections and re-examined them, by expert review and by broad DNA testing, to count how often parasite material was present and unreported. The nearest attempts are a pan-pathogen microarray, PathoChip, built with probes for viruses, bacteria, fungi, parasites and helminths and shown to work on formalin-fixed tumor tissue 93. Its developers then reported 'parasitic signatures' in oral and oropharyngeal, ovarian and breast cancers 94,95,96. Those reports come from one group, have not been independently replicated, and came before the reanalyses that showed how contamination and database errors create false microbial signals 21,52. They are leads, not counts. In Thailand, where the liver fluke is common, a targeted PCR found Opisthorchis viverrini DNA in 5 of 6 resected cholangiocarcinomas, but also in 7 of 12 liver-cell cancers, so finding the DNA did not by itself mark the cancer the fluke causes 82. The nearest figures for what routine work misses are the 18%-against-49% gap for schistosome eggs in cervical tissue 12 and the 20% of presumed angiostrongyliasis specimens in which only PCR found the worm 81, and neither can be carried over to tumors. A sequencing service like the one in Basel 13, applied to tumor blocks under five years old 69, with rigorous removal of human reads 70 and independent reanalysis of the kind that overturned the retracted microbiome work 21, would answer it.
Several smaller facts are also missing from the published record, as far as the searches behind this page could find. No published study has run a clinical cancer gene panel against purified parasite DNA. The claim that a panel built for human genes would miss it is an inference from how such panels work, not a measurement: amplicon panels copy only the stretches of DNA flanked by primers, short DNA starters matched to human sequence, while capture panels fish out human target regions with matching probes. One clinical laboratory has described discarding the reads that match nothing human 71, but no survey across accredited tumor-sequencing laboratories was found. No study has fixed known helminth (parasitic worm) material, processed it to paraffin, and scored how recognizable it remains. No study has counted how often a uniformly negative antibody panel is followed by an organism stain. This page could not source the temperature of the paraffin bath. And this page could not open the current CAP protocol documents to check whether any carries a place to record a coexisting infection.
Two practical limits constrain any search of old tissue. Archived blocks age: parasite DNA was recovered from all 6 alveolar echinococcosis blocks stored for less than six years, but, by subtraction from the published counts, from only 3 of the 9 older ones 69. And one widely quoted timing rule could not be checked at its source: the 6-to-72-hour fixation window is cited here from a 2026 study restating the ASCO/CAP guidelines 6, because the abstract of the receptor guideline itself does not state it 46.
How this connects to parasites and cancer
The parasite-cancer links that are established are counted through infection measured in people who have the cancer. IARC's 2024 accounting attributes 5,900 squamous cell carcinomas of the bladder to Schistosoma haematobium and 3,800 intrahepatic cholangiocarcinomas, cancers of the bile ducts inside the liver, to two liver flukes, Opisthorchis viverrini and Clonorchis sinensis, out of 2.3 million cancers attributed to infection worldwide 17. Those fractions were estimated mainly from how often the infection is found in people who have the cancer, and the parasite fractions were carried over unchanged from IARC's 2018 estimates 17. Whatever method measured infection in those patients, whether eggs, antibodies or tissue, therefore sets a ceiling on what can be counted: an infection nobody tested for never enters the count.
What this page supports is narrow and solid. A negative pathology report is evidence about the questions that were asked of the tissue that reached the glass 3,12. Routine sections demonstrably miss focal parasite material that a fuller look finds 12,65, failures of recognition are documented 28,29, and the tools to look properly exist and work on archived tissue 13,69. That is a measurement gap, and it is real.
What this page does not support is any estimate of how often parasites are actually present in tumors. The published cases found for this page mostly run the other way: parasitic lesions suspected or diagnosed as cancer and then corrected by excision, a larger biopsy or autopsy 19,20,65. Where denominators exist, they depend on place. In a Tanzanian referral pathology department, routine reports recorded Schistosoma haematobium eggs in 25.2% of 481 bladder cancers over ten years, most often with squamous cell carcinoma 14. By contrast, lung fluke disease accounted for 0.1% of 1,699 cases of pleurisy, inflammation of the lining around the lungs, diagnosed by surgical biopsy in Japan 97. A systematic review found parasites beyond the established three inside cancers or tumors, among them the tapeworm Echinococcus, the threadworm Strongyloides and the liver fluke Fasciola, and concluded that cause and effect had not been shown 98. The tapeworm cancer remains a single case 29.
So the honest position is the season's question, stated precisely. The established numbers are real, measured by people who looked, and they are also, by construction, the numbers of what anyone has looked for 17. Whether looking harder would raise them a little, a lot or not at all is unknown. The experiment that would tell us has become technically feasible 13,70: broad sequencing of a consecutive series of recent tumor blocks, with careful removal of human reads, contamination controls and independent reanalysis. Small, uncontrolled versions exist 82,93, but the decisive version has not been done.
Where it connects
Topics on the map
On the map
A star in Cancer, found and missed, one of 7. Six steps between the tumor and the diagnosis, and every one of them was designed to answer a different question than the one a parasite would raise.
Sources
98 sources, numbered as they are cited. Every one was checked against PubMed or its publisher before it was cited here; the note under each says what it shows and what it does not.
- 1Haghbin N, Oveisi B, Banitaba AP. Automated variable power cold microwave tissue processing: A novel universal tissue processing protocol without using formaldehyde and xylene.doi:10.1016/j.acthis.2022.151880 · PMID 35344896
Lays out the routine chain from fixation to slide and names formaldehyde and xylene as hazards; the 97-minute processor it describes is a prototype, not routine practice.
- 2Kumarapeli AR, Bellamy W, Olgaard E, et al. Short-Duration Rapid Chilling of Mastectomy Specimens Does Not Interfere With Breast Cancer Biomarker and Molecular Testing.doi:10.5858/arpa.2017-0377-OA · PMID 29932859
Gives two working numbers: mastectomies sliced at 4-mm intervals, and FFPE DNA that amplified successfully in 300- to 400-base-pair stretches, offered as evidence the DNA was well preserved rather than as a measure of fragmentation; it is one laboratory's experience.
- 3Fitzgibbons PL, Bradley LA, Fatheree LA, et al. Principles of analytic validation of immunohistochemical assays: Guideline from the College of American Pathologists Pathology and Laboratory Quality Center.doi:10.5858/arpa.2013-0610-CP · PMID 24646069
Requires every antibody test to be validated for its analyte before clinical use; it says nothing about organisms, and one panelist lists a commercial laboratory affiliation.
- 4Srigley JR, McGowan T, Maclean A, et al. Standardized synoptic cancer pathology reporting: a population-based approach.doi:10.1002/jso.21282 · PMID 19466743
Describes CAP-defined checklist content and its province-wide rollout in Canada with rising completeness; it does not list the checklist items.
- 5Thavarajah R, Mudimbaimannar VK, Elizabeth J, et al. Chemical and physical basics of routine formaldehyde fixation.doi:10.4103/0973-029X.102496 · PMID 23248474
A narrative review compiling the chemistry of formalin (3.7% formaldehyde, the methylene glycol equilibrium, 24 to 48 hours for initial cross-links); its figures are gathered from earlier work rather than newly measured.
- 6Ndengue CP, Atangana PJA, Ateba GR, et al. Pre-analytical variables affecting breast cancer biomarker expression: A controlled single-specimen study of fixation duration, cold ischemia time, and fixative preparation in a low-resource setting.doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0343185 · PMID 42247401
Restates the ASCO/CAP timing rules (fixative within 1 hour, 6 to 72 hours of fixation) and measures marker loss after 2 hours of delay; it is one tumor cut into 50 cores, so it is a technical benchmark, not population evidence.
- 7Salehi E, Hedayati MT, Zoll J, et al. Discrimination of Aspergillosis, Mucormycosis, Fusariosis, and Scedosporiosis in Formalin-Fixed Paraffin-Embedded Tissue Specimens by Use of Multiple Real-Time Quantitative PCR Assays.doi:10.1128/JCM.01185-16 · PMID 27605714
DNA testing of 102 archived specimens reassigned several fungal diagnoses made by shape, and used two 4- to 5-micrometer sections each; molds, not parasites.
- 8Tran T, Sundaram CP, Bahler CD, et al. Correcting the Shrinkage Effects of Formalin Fixation and Tissue Processing for Renal Tumors: toward Standardization of Pathological Reporting of Tumor Size.doi:10.7150/jca.12094 · PMID 26185538
Measures 11.4% shrinkage from fresh tissue to slide in 34 kidney tumors; it does not measure parasites, whose identification can depend on size.
- 9Grogan T, Reinhardt K, Jaramillo M, et al. An update on "special stain" histochemistry with emphasis on automation.doi:10.1097/00125480-200007020-00006 · PMID 10721418
Describes the 20 to 25 special stains a surgical pathology laboratory keeps, including stains for microorganisms; it does not say how often they are ordered on tumors.
- 10Elmore JG, Longton GM, Carney PA, et al. Diagnostic concordance among pathologists interpreting breast biopsy specimens.doi:10.1001/jama.2015.1405 · PMID 25781441
115 pathologists agreed with an expert reference on 96% of invasive cancers but 48% of atypia, reading one slide per case; it measures interpretation, not sampling.
- 11Fridland S, Mehta V, Jager L, et al. Not all errors are created equal: assessment of amended diagnoses at a major academic center.doi:10.1093/ajcp/aqag005 · PMID 41807328
0.33% of final surgical pathology reports were amended over five years at one center, within CAP benchmarks; amendments catch errors someone noticed, not unasked questions.
- 12Poggensee G, Sahebali S, Van Marck E, et al. Diagnosis of genital cervical schistosomiasis: comparison of cytological, histopathological and parasitological examination.doi:10.4269/ajtmh.2001.65.233 · PMID 11561710
The clearest measurement of sampling loss for a parasite: in the same 228 women, eggs were found in 49% by squash, 18% by sections and 3% by smears; it concerns cervical tissue, not tumors.
- 13Hamelin B, Hosch S, Neidhöfer C, et al. Unbiased DNA Pathogen Detection in Tissues: Real-World Experience With Metagenomic Sequencing in Pathology.doi:10.1016/j.labinv.2025.104254 · PMID 41167475
A routine service sequencing 623 archived infectious-pathology samples in Basel (36.8% positive, 9 parasites, 9.6% uninterpretable); it was not applied to unselected tumors.
- 14Yohana C, Bakuza JS, Kinung'hi SM, Nyundo BA, Rambau PF. The trend of schistosomiasis related bladder cancer in the lake zone, Tanzania: a retrospective review over 10 years period.doi:10.1186/s13027-023-00491-1 · PMID 36800971
Schistosome eggs recorded in 25.2% of 481 histologically confirmed bladder cancers at one referral center over ten years, most often with squamous cell carcinoma; the reports were read retrospectively, and how thoroughly eggs were sought is not stated.
- 15Haley L, Parimi V, Jiang L, et al. Diagnostic Utility of Gene Fusion Panel to Detect Gene Fusions in Fresh and Formalin-Fixed, Paraffin-Embedded Cancer Specimens.doi:10.1016/j.jmoldx.2021.07.015 · PMID 34358677
A 329-specimen validation in which 141 solid tumors were tested as fixed tissue and karyotyping served as one comparator; it is about fusion genes, not organisms.
- 16Ross JS, Wang K, Gay L, et al. Comprehensive Genomic Profiling of Carcinoma of Unknown Primary Site: New Routes to Targeted Therapies.doi:10.1001/jamaoncol.2014.216 · PMID 26182302
A commercial panel found at least one human alteration in 192 of 200 tumors; all 17 authors listed Foundation Medicine, which sells the assay.
- 17Rumgay H, Georges D, Huang Y, et al. Global burden of cancer attributable to infections in 2024: a worldwide incidence analysis.doi:10.1016/S1470-2045(26)00307-4 · PMID 42805198
IARC's 2024 count: 5,900 bladder and 3,800 bile-duct cancers attributed to parasites, with attributable fractions estimated mainly from infection prevalence in people with cancer; the full text available here strips organism names, so the parasite assigned to each figure is read from the paper's agent list.
- 18Weaver DL, Ashikaga T, Krag DN, et al. Effect of occult metastases on survival in node-negative breast cancer.doi:10.1056/NEJMoa1008108 · PMID 21247310
Two deeper levels through 'negative' sentinel nodes, examined with routine and cytokeratin antibody stains after a first look designed to catch deposits larger than 2 mm, found hidden cancer in 15.9% of 3,887 patients, with a 1.2-point survival difference; it measures what one plane and one stain miss, not parasites.
- 19Silver SA, Erozan YS, Hruban RH. Cerebral cysticercosis mimicking malignant glioma: a case report.doi:10.1159/000333767 · PMID 8629426
A needle biopsy read as malignant glioma that proved to be cysticercosis on excision; a single case.
- 20Ermilov VV, Smirnov AV, Snigur GL, et al. [Pulmonary larval paragonimiasis mimicking lung cancer].doi:10.17116/patol201880260-63 · PMID 29697674
A frozen section read as glandular cancer led to resection, and lung fluke disease was diagnosed after the patient's death; a single case, in Russian.
- 21Gihawi A, Ge Y, Lu J, et al. Major data analysis errors invalidate cancer microbiome findings.doi:10.1128/mbio.01607-23 · PMID 37811944
The reanalysis showing most reported cancer microbes were absent from the samples and more than a dozen follow-up studies likely invalid; it addresses bacteria, not parasites.
- 22Poore GD, Kopylova E, Zhu Q, et al. Retraction Note: Microbiome analyses of blood and tissues suggest cancer diagnostic approach.doi:10.1038/s41586-024-07656-x · PMID 38926587
The formal retraction notice for the 2020 paper; PubMed holds no abstract for it.
- 23Ould Ismail AA, Kale S, McGonagle K, et al. Adherence to Synoptic Cancer Pathology Reporting Among Pathologists in the National Department of Veterans Affairs Health Care System.doi:10.5858/arpa.2024-0229-OA · PMID 39514644
Across the US Department of Veterans Affairs, 48% of 1,618 cancer reports from 2019 to 2021 were synoptic: 77% of resections but 19% of biopsies; four cancer types in one health system.
- 24Yıldız T, İlçe Z, Turan G, et al. [Parasites in the Etiology of Pediatric Appendicitis].doi:10.5152/tpd.2015.3737 · PMID 26470923
Routine histology found pinworms or Taenia in 14 of 846 children's appendices; the abstract's printed 0.39% does not match its own counts.
- 25Al Laham O, Abdul Khalek G, Alboushi H, et al. An incidentally diagnosed primary pancreatic body hydatid cyst: A case report and literature review.doi:10.1016/j.ijscr.2024.109392 · PMID 38367420
A pancreatic body mass seen on imaging and resected with the tail and spleen, which histology showed to be a hydatid cyst; a single case, and evidence that the pipeline does name parasites it sees.
- 26Dursun N, Memis B, Pehlivanoglu B, et al. Adenomyomas of the Gallbladder: An Analysis of Frequency, Clinicopathologic Associations, and Relationship to Carcinoma of a Malformative Lesion.doi:10.5858/arpa.2022-0379-OA · PMID 37134225
A lesion appeared in 9.3% of 203 gallbladders embedded whole but 3.3% of a separate series of 2,347 routinely sampled ones, a comparison across cohorts rather than within the same specimens; a benign lesion, not a parasite.
- 27Selves J, Long-Mira E, Mathieu MC, et al. Immunohistochemistry for Diagnosis of Metastatic Carcinomas of Unknown Primary Site.doi:10.3390/cancers10040108 · PMID 29621151
Describes the CK7/CK20-led antibody algorithm for cancers of unknown origin; a review of human markers, with no accuracy figures of its own.
- 28Trecourt A, Radobonirina M. [Infectious cysts and pseudocysts: When parasites want to mimic tumors!].doi:10.1016/j.annpat.2025.04.003 · PMID 40328550
A 2025 French review stating that parasitic cysts are rarely encountered by pathologists and full of pitfalls, and recommending expert and molecular review; it gives no rates.
- 29Muehlenbachs A, Bhatnagar J, Agudelo CA, et al. Malignant Transformation of Hymenolepis nana in a Human Host.doi:10.1056/NEJMoa1505892 · PMID 26535513
Tumor-like cells in a man with HIV, unrecognizable as tapeworm on the slide, identified by a PCR targeting all eukaryotes; a single case, without published replication.
- 30Do H, Dobrovic A. Sequence artifacts in DNA from formalin-fixed tissues: causes and strategies for minimization.doi:10.1373/clinchem.2014.223040 · PMID 25421801
A mini-review stating that DNA extracted from formalin-fixed tissue is fragmented and carries lesions, such as deaminated cytosines and abasic sites, that are sources of sequence artifacts; written for human mutation calling, not organisms.
- 31Miquelestorena-Standley E, Jourdan ML, Collin C, et al. Effect of decalcification protocols on immunohistochemistry and molecular analyses of bone samples.doi:10.1038/s41379-020-0503-6 · PMID 32094425
Hydrochloric acid and long formic-acid decalcification caused false-negative antibody and DNA results in 35 bone samples, while EDTA did not; it did not study organisms.
- 32Titford M. The long history of hematoxylin.doi:10.1080/10520290500138372 · PMID 16195172
A historical review: logwood found in 1502, used by microscopists from the mid-1800s; it is a history, not a study.
- 33Puchtler H, Meloan SN. On the chemistry of formaldehyde fixation and its effects on immunohistochemical reactions.doi:10.1007/BF00501395 · PMID 3997553
States that formalin fixation was discovered accidentally by F. Blum in 1893, and that formaldehyde's methylene cross-links resist washing; chemistry, and it predates modern retrieval methods.
- 34Musiał A, Gryglewski RW, Kielczewski S, et al. Formalin use in anatomical and histological science in the 19th and 20th centuries.PMID 28275269
A history of formalin naming Ferdinand Blum among those who brought formaldehyde into tissue fixation; the abstract gives no exact year for his work.
- 35Berry A, Iriart X, Fillaux J, Magnaval JF. [Urinary schistosomiasis and cancer].doi:10.1007/s13149-017-0547-4 · PMID 28185084
A review, in French with an English abstract, recording that A. R. Ferguson, professor of pathology in Cairo, reported from 40 autopsies in 1911 a likely association between bladder cancer and schistosome granulomas; history, not a new measurement.
- 36Tsoucalas G, Laios K, Karamanou M, Gennimata V, Androutsos G. The fascinating germ theories on cancer pathogenesis.PMID 24659685
A history of the germ theories of cancer, recording the 1926 Nobel Prize to Johannes Fibiger for the nematode Spiroptera as a cause of cancer; a historical review.
- 37Hitchcock CR, Bell ET. Studies on the nematode parasite, Gongylonema neoplasticum (spiroptera neoplasticum), and avitaminosis A in the forestomach of rats: comparison with Fibiger's results.PMID 14939031
The re-examination that set Fibiger's worm against vitamin A deficiency in the rat forestomach; PubMed holds no abstract, so this page reports only what the title states.
- 38Stolt CM, Klein G, Jansson ATR. An analysis of a wrong Nobel Prize-Johannes Fibiger, 1926: a study in the Nobel archives.doi:10.1016/S0065-230X(04)92001-5 · PMID 15530554
A study of the Nobel archives whose title calls Fibiger's 1926 prize a wrong one; PubMed holds no abstract for it.
- 39Arnason U. 50 years after--examination of some circumstances around the establishment of the correct chromosome number of man.doi:10.1111/j.2006.0018-0661.01963.x · PMID 17362356
Checks the 1956 discovery of 46 human chromosomes against the laboratory logbook and finds the participants' accounts inconsistent; it is history, not cytogenetic method.
- 40Taylor CR, Mason DY. The immunohistological detection of intracellular immunoglobulin in formalin-paraffin sections from multiple myeloma and related conditions using the immunoperoxidase technique.PMID 4219910
An early demonstration that an enzyme-labeled antibody can find a chosen protein in formalin-fixed paraffin sections, in 33 plasma cell tumors.
- 41Shi SR, Key ME, Kalra KL. Antigen retrieval in formalin-fixed, paraffin-embedded tissues: an enhancement method for immunohistochemical staining based on microwave oven heating of tissue sections.doi:10.1177/39.6.1709656 · PMID 1709656
Introduced heat-based antigen retrieval (39 of 52 antibodies improved); the first author's listed affiliation is BioGenex Laboratories, a reagent company, a commercial interest the paper's readers should weigh.
- 42Zehir A, Benayed R, Shah RH, et al. Mutational landscape of metastatic cancer revealed from prospective clinical sequencing of 10,000 patients.doi:10.1038/nm.4333 · PMID 28481359
More than 10,000 patients' tumors sequenced prospectively with one center's clinical gene panel; human alterations only, and it says nothing about non-human reads.
- 43Roy S, Coldren C, Karunamurthy A, et al. Standards and Guidelines for Validating Next-Generation Sequencing Bioinformatics Pipelines: A Joint Recommendation of the Association for Molecular Pathology and the College of American Pathologists.doi:10.1016/j.jmoldx.2017.11.003 · PMID 29154853
Seventeen consensus recommendations for validating clinical sequencing software, written because laboratories varied widely in how they did it; several authors list commercial testing companies (Invitae, Color Genomics, Sema4, PathGroup) or ARUP Laboratories, a University of Utah reference laboratory, and its abstract does not address non-human reads.
- 44Novis DA, Gephardt GN, Zarbo RJ. Interinstitutional comparison of frozen section consultation in small hospitals: a College of American Pathologists Q-Probes study of 18,532 frozen section consultation diagnoses in 233 small hospitals.PMID 15456172
A 1994 audit in which 1.8% of non-deferred frozen-section diagnoses (316 of 17,673) disagreed with final slides, mostly underdiagnosed tumors through sampling error; it concerns frozen sections in small hospitals only.
- 45Kronz JD, Westra WH, Epstein JI. Mandatory second opinion surgical pathology at a large referral hospital.doi:10.1002/(SICI)1097-0142(19991201)86:11<2426::AID-CNCR34>3.0.CO;2-3 · PMID 10590387
Second review of 6,171 outside cases changed 86 diagnoses (1.4%) in ways that altered treatment or prognosis; it measures disagreement about questions already asked.
- 46Hammond ME, Hayes DF, Dowsett M, et al. American Society of Clinical Oncology/College Of American Pathologists guideline recommendations for immunohistochemical testing of estrogen and progesterone receptors in breast cancer.doi:10.1200/JCO.2009.25.6529 · PMID 20404251
The guideline panel's statement that up to 20% of receptor tests worldwide may be inaccurate, mostly from handling, thresholds and interpretation; panel disclosures were not read for this page, and the abstract does not state the fixation window.
- 47Goldsmith JD, Troxell ML, Roy-Chowdhuri S, et al. Principles of Analytic Validation of Immunohistochemical Assays: Guideline Update.doi:10.5858/arpa.2023-0483-CP · PMID 38391878
The 2024 update to CAP's antibody-validation rules, extended to new scoring systems and cytology; some panelists list consulting firms, and organisms are not its subject.
- 48Harper PS. The discovery of the human chromosome number in Lund, 1955-1956.doi:10.1007/s00439-005-0121-x · PMID 16463025
A history recording that the correct number, 46, ended more than 30 years in which the human number was thought to be 48, and that previously accepted conclusions shaped how earlier results were read.
- 49De Marzo AM, Fedor HH, Gage WR, et al. Inadequate formalin fixation decreases reliability of p27 immunohistochemical staining: probing optimal fixation time using high-density tissue microarrays.doi:10.1053/hupa.2002.126187 · PMID 12196928
The reversal on fixation time: underfixed prostate tissue stained worse than tissue fixed for up to 8 days; it tested one protein, p27, in one organ.
- 50Gerlinger M, Rowan AJ, Horswell S, et al. Intratumor heterogeneity and branched evolution revealed by multiregion sequencing.doi:10.1056/NEJMoa1113205 · PMID 22397650
63% to 69% of mutations were not detectable in every region of the same kidney cancers; a small number of tumors, and human mutations only.
- 51Che J, Du J, Piao Y, et al. Fungal species identification in FFPE tissues: A comparative evaluation of droplet digital PCR, ITS sequencing, and metagenomic next-generation sequencing.doi:10.1093/mmy/myag049 · PMID 42133463
On 111 archived fungal specimens, metagenomic sequencing named the species in 81.1% against 64.9% and 50.5% for two targeted DNA tests, and caught two rare fungi misdiagnosed as Aspergillus; fungi, not parasites.
- 52Ge Y, Lu J, Puiu D, Revsine M, Salzberg SL. Comprehensive analysis of microbial content in whole-genome sequencing samples from The Cancer Genome Atlas project.doi:10.1126/scitranslmed.ads6335 · PMID 40901923
Reanalysis of all 5,734 whole-genome samples in TCGA, across 25 cancer types, finding microbial presence far smaller than reported and many named species possibly absent; bacteria, viruses, archaea and fungi, not parasites.
- 53Warren JR, Marshall B. Unidentified curved bacilli on gastric epithelium in active chronic gastritis.PMID 6134060
The letter reporting unidentified curved bacilli on the stomach lining; PubMed holds no abstract, and the organism was not named in it.
- 54Relman DA, Schmidt TM, MacDermott RP, Falkow S. Identification of the uncultured bacillus of Whipple's disease.doi:10.1056/NEJM199207303270501 · PMID 1377787
A bacillus associated with Whipple's disease for 85 years, never cultured, was named from DNA copied out of five patients' tissue with broad-range primers; bacteria, by the method this page argues for with parasites.
- 55Feng H, Shuda M, Chang Y, et al. Clonal integration of a polyomavirus in human Merkel cell carcinoma.doi:10.1126/science.1152586 · PMID 18202256
Found a new virus in 8 of 10 Merkel cell carcinomas by subtracting human sequence from tumor transcripts; it shows what a research pipeline can see, not what clinical pipelines do.
- 56Poore GD, Kopylova E, Zhu Q, et al. Microbiome analyses of blood and tissues suggest cancer diagnostic approach.doi:10.1038/s41586-020-2095-1 · PMID 32214244
RETRACTED in 2024. Claimed cancer-type microbial signatures in 18,116 TCGA tissue and blood samples from patients with 33 cancer types; one coauthor listed a commercial genomics affiliation (Clarity Genomics). Cited only as the claim that was withdrawn.
- 57Focke CM, Decker T, van Diest PJ. The reliability of histological grade in breast cancer core needle biopsies depends on biopsy size: a comparative study with subsequent surgical excisions.doi:10.1111/his.13036 · PMID 27417415
More millimeters of core gave grades closer to the excised tumor (83% against 68%) in 300 breast cancers; observational, and about grade, not organisms.
- 58Lebwohl B, Kapel RC, Neugut AI, et al. Adherence to biopsy guidelines increases celiac disease diagnosis.doi:10.1016/j.gie.2011.03.1236 · PMID 21601201
Submitting four or more duodenal pieces was linked to more than double the diagnosis rate (1.8% against 0.7%) in 132,352 patients; an association in retrospective data, for celiac disease.
- 59Suganuma N, Matsubara Y, Takahashi A, et al. Impact of Warm Ischemia Time on HER2 Expression in Breast Cancer Surgical Specimens.doi:10.21873/anticanres.17350 · PMID 39626910
Real handling times in 277 breast operations at one Japanese center (median cold ischemia 37 minutes, fixation 43 hours); it does not measure anything beyond receptor staining.
- 60Vassilakopoulou M, Parisi F, Siddiqui S, et al. Preanalytical variables and phosphoepitope expression in FFPE tissue: quantitative epitope assessment after variable cold ischemic time.doi:10.1038/labinvest.2014.139 · PMID 25418580
Shows loss of antigenicity for several phosphoproteins within 1 to 2 hours of delay in 93 breast cancers, and cites earlier reports of degradation within 30 minutes; it concerns labile molecules, not whole organisms.
- 61Al-Nattah S, Martin A, Normington L, et al. Reduced cervical sampling of hysterectomy specimens with negative margins on conization: An opportunity to improve resource utilization.doi:10.1093/ajcp/aqae139 · PMID 39441180
Submitting the whole cervix by protocol averaged 16 blocks per case (range 4 to 41); the authors propose one representative section per quadrant, saving about two to six hours of laboratory work; a small study arguing for less tissue, not more.
- 62Bindhu P, Krishnapillai R, Thomas P, Jayanthi P. Facts in artifacts.doi:10.4103/0973-029X.125206 · PMID 24574659
A review of processing artifacts: acid formalin hematin, a brown pigment formed from unbuffered formalin and blood, 'may simulate microorganisms'; fungi, fibers and fragments of another patient's tissue can contaminate a slide; and thin, narrow specimens curl during processing, so they are hard to orient when embedded and end up cut at a slant.
- 63Honeywell R, Donner M, Criswell S. Thorough formalin fixation confers a protective effect for histochemical and immunohistochemical testing on tissues exposed to prolonged time in ethanol, xylene, heat, or paraffin.doi:10.1007/s00418-026-02545-y · PMID 42825935
In tissue fixed for three to five weeks, an extra 24 hours in absolute ethanol, xylene, molten paraffin or on a heated embedding station caused no visible change in structure or routine staining, and most antibody tests were preserved; it does not give the temperature of the paraffin bath.
- 64Kiernan JA. Does progressive nuclear staining with hemalum (alum hematoxylin) involve DNA, and what is the nature of the dye-chromatin complex?doi:10.1080/10520295.2017.1399466 · PMID 29320873
Experiments showing that the hematoxylin dye complex binds the phosphate of DNA electrostatically; it explains the blue of H&E, not what a reader will notice.
- 65Kim KE, Jung SS, Park HS, et al. The first case report of Paragonimus westermani infection diagnosed by transbronchial lung cryobiopsy.doi:10.1016/j.ijid.2022.12.041 · PMID 36608785
Fluke eggs found by cryobiopsy in a patient who also had a forceps biopsy; the authors credit the larger specimen. A single case.
- 66Sluijter CE, van Lonkhuijzen LR, van Slooten HJ, et al. The effects of implementing synoptic pathology reporting in cancer diagnosis: a systematic review.doi:10.1007/s00428-016-1935-8 · PMID 27097810
Thirty-two of 33 studies found checklist reports more complete, especially for margins and invasion; the items reviewed are human tumor features, and clinical benefit was not shown.
- 67Rassy E, Pavlidis N. The diagnostic challenges of patients with carcinoma of unknown primary.doi:10.1080/14737140.2020.1807948 · PMID 32779501
Antibody panels name a single tissue of origin in 10.8% to 51% of cancers of unknown primary; a review, so its ranges come from other studies.
- 68Özmen A, Mıstık R, Alver O, et al. [The Pneumocystis jirovecii colonization in bronchoalveolar lavage (BAL) and bronchial washing and the comparison of methods which are used in diagnosis].doi:10.5578/tt.2954 · PMID 24506746
Three classic stains found the organism in none of 100 lung-wash samples while antibody and DNA tests found it in 13 and 16; a fungus in fluid, not a parasite in tissue.
- 69Grimm J, Krickl J, Beck A, et al. Establishing and evaluation of a polymerase chain reaction for the detection of Echinococcus multilocularis in human tissue.doi:10.1371/journal.pntd.0009155 · PMID 33630840
A validated parasite PCR and antibody that work on archived blocks: all 6 viable-lesion blocks stored under six years were positive, against 3 of the 9 older ones by subtraction from the counts; one parasite, one disease.
- 70Frolova M, Maguire B, Duessmann H, et al. HumanFilt: a multi-reference host depletion pipeline improves Fusobacterium detection accuracy in tumor WGS data sets.doi:10.1128/msystems.00550-26 · PMID 42446235
Shows that clean recovery of non-human reads from tumor genomes needed three human references and removed over 99.9% of human reads; ten tumors, bacteria only.
- 71Cimino PJ, Zhao G, Wang D, et al. Detection of viral pathogens in high grade gliomas from unmapped next-generation sequencing data.doi:10.1016/j.yexmp.2014.03.010 · PMID 24704430
One academic clinical laboratory mined the previously discarded non-human reads of its 151-gene FFPE cancer panel, averaging about 38,000 reads per case (1.9%); the Epstein-Barr virus hits were not confirmed by in situ hybridization in any of the four cases with material for it; viruses only, 21 tumors.
- 72Zapatka M, Borozan I, Brewer DS, et al. The landscape of viral associations in human cancers.doi:10.1038/s41588-019-0558-9 · PMID 32025001
A research consortium found viral sequence in 382 of 2,658 cancer genomes using three pipelines; viruses, in research data, not clinical reports.
- 73Nejman D, Livyatan I, Fuks G, et al. The human tumor microbiome is composed of tumor type-specific intracellular bacteria.doi:10.1126/science.aay9189 · PMID 32467386
Bacteria found inside both cancer and immune cells in 1,526 tumors across seven cancer types; bacteria only, and the authors note that the low biomass makes this work hard.
- 74Battaglia TW, Mimpen IL, Traets JJH, et al. A pan-cancer analysis of the microbiome in metastatic cancer.doi:10.1016/j.cell.2024.03.021 · PMID 38599211
Microbial communities in 4,160 metastatic tumor biopsies, with Fusobacterium tied to resistance to immunotherapy in lung cancer; one author lists the Hartwig Medical Foundation, which holds the sequencing data, and the abstract does not report parasites.
- 75Neveling K, Mantere T, Vermeulen S, et al. Next-generation cytogenetics: Comprehensive assessment of 52 hematological malignancy genomes by optical genome mapping.doi:10.1016/j.ajhg.2021.06.001 · PMID 34237281
States that full structural analysis of blood cancers still combines karyotype, FISH and arrays, and tests a newer method in 52 patients; it does not concern solid tumors.
- 76Campbell WS, Rous BA, Dubois S, et al. Advancements in Interoperability: Achieving Anatomic Pathology Reports That Adhere to International Standards and Are Both Human-Readable and Readily Computable.doi:10.1200/CCI-24-00180 · PMID 39908464
Describes the required data elements of cancer protocols as 'the minimum set of evidence-based, clinically actionable parameters'; it is about coding and interoperability, and does not list the optional fields.
- 77Torous VF, Simpson RW, Balani JP, et al. College of American Pathologists Cancer Protocols: From Optimizing Cancer Patient Care to Facilitating Interoperable Reporting and Downstream Data Use.doi:10.1200/CCI.20.00104 · PMID 33439728
A review stating that the CAP cancer protocols have guided American cancer reporting for more than 35 years; it describes the system rather than auditing its use.
- 78Paik J, Ellis CL, Henriksen KJ, Chang A. An International Survey of Genitourinary and Renal Pathologists Regarding Evaluation of the Non-Neoplastic Parenchyma in Kidney Cancer Specimens.doi:10.1177/10668969231177408 · PMID 37226477
Records that CAP's 2010 update required evaluation of the non-cancerous kidney in tumor nephrectomies, evidence that a required item can reach beyond the tumor; the rest is a survey of practice.
- 79Wolff AC, Somerfield MR, Dowsett M, et al. Human Epidermal Growth Factor Receptor 2 Testing in Breast Cancer: ASCO-College of American Pathologists Guideline Update.doi:10.1200/JCO.22.02864 · PMID 37284804
Affirms the 2018 HER2 recommendations but makes the line between 'IHC 0' and '1+' newly relevant, because a drug was approved for tumors in that range; an example of a report question changing with treatment.
- 80Allison KH, Hammond MEH, Dowsett M, et al. Estrogen and Progesterone Receptor Testing in Breast Cancer: ASCO/CAP Guideline Update.doi:10.1200/JCO.19.02309 · PMID 31928404
The 2020 update that added an 'ER Low Positive' reporting category for tumors with 1% to 10% of nuclei staining; a guideline about one receptor pair, not about organisms.
- 81Rodriguez R, da Silva AC, Müller CA, et al. PCR for the diagnosis of abdominal angiostrongyliasis in formalin-fixed paraffin-embedded human tissue.doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0093658 · PMID 24705328
PCR found worm DNA in 4 of 20 bowel specimens where sections showed only the tissue reaction, with 55% sensitivity and 100% specificity; small numbers, one worm.
- 82Suksumek N, Leelawat K, Leelawat S, Russell B, Lek-Uthai U. TaqMan real-time PCR assay for specific detection of Opisthorchis viverrini DNA in Thai patients with hepatocellular carcinoma and cholangiocarcinoma.doi:10.1016/j.exppara.2008.01.018 · PMID 18329641
Fluke DNA in 5 of 6 cholangiocarcinomas and 7 of 12 liver-cell cancers from resections, with no association found between cancer type and the parasite; 18 tumors in all.
- 83Roh CK, Jung MJ. Laparoscopic excision for ectopic peritoneal paragonimiasis mimicking a gastric duplication cyst: A case report.doi:10.1016/j.amsu.2021.102754 · PMID 34484726
A lung fluke in the abdomen, taken for a cyst on imaging and diagnosed on excision; the authors note in general that eggs in sputum and biopsy specimens may be hard to detect 'due to an insufficient amount'. A single case.
- 84Mainland N, Madiraju S, Nwogu S, et al. Phimosis of foreskin uncovering schistosomiasis of the urinary bladder: a case report.doi:10.21037/tau-2025-182 · PMID 40687665
A frozen section of a bladder mass in a 10-year-old Sudanese immigrant was read as rhabdoid malignancy; the permanent sections showed numerous schistosome eggs and no cancer. A single case.
- 85Querzoli G, Ortalli M, Varani S, et al. Tonsillar Leishmaniasis: A Rare Clinical Entity Mimicking Malignancy in the Oropharynx - A Case Series from Northeastern Italy.doi:10.1007/s12105-025-01773-3 · PMID 40138028
Five tonsil swellings that mimicked cancer between 2014 and 2024 proved to be leishmaniasis, seen on histology in four and confirmed by PCR in all five; a case series from one region.
- 86Hu D, Jin W, Ding H, et al. Spirometra mansoni sparganosis identified by metagenomic next-generation sequencing: a case report.doi:10.1016/j.ijid.2022.12.038 · PMID 36592686
Sequencing of an archived block corrected a cysticercosis diagnosis to sparganosis; a single case, and two authors work for KingMed Diagnostics, a commercial laboratory.
- 87Khor LY, Neo CC, Prathaban K, et al. Deep learning model for automated detection of Helicobacter pylori and intestinal metaplasia on gastric biopsy digital whole slide images.doi:10.1093/ajcp/aqaf110 · PMID 40996022
A tool trained to find Helicobacter pylori on scanned gastric biopsies scored 0.617 on the F1 scale for the organisms themselves, against 0.861 for intestinal metaplasia; one organism, the one it was trained for, on 180 slides.
- 88Parra-Medina R, Zambrano-Betancourt C, Peña-Rojas S, et al. Detection of Helicobacter pylori Infection in Histopathological Gastric Biopsies Using Deep Learning Models.doi:10.3390/jimaging11070226 · PMID 40710613
Deep-learning detection of Helicobacter pylori on 100 whole-slide images, noting that some scanned images lack the resolution to show the bacteria; the PubMed title drops the italicized organism name.
- 89Roure S, Pérez-Quílez O, Vallès X, et al. Schistosomiasis Among Female Migrants in Non-endemic Countries: Neglected Among the Neglected? A Pilot Study.doi:10.3389/fpubh.2022.778110 · PMID 35372213
Seropositive migrant women in Barcelona had a median of 41 clinic visits before schistosomiasis was diagnosed; a pilot study of 51 women, about clinical, not pathological, delay.
- 90Tawfik O, Davis M, Dillon S, et al. Whole Slide Imaging of Pap Cell Block Preparations versus Liquid-Based Thin-Layer Cervical Cytology: A Comparative Study Evaluating the Detection of Organisms and Nonneoplastic Findings.doi:10.1159/000365046 · PMID 25033897
Trichomonas identified in 10 of 11 positive cervical samples when organisms were part of what was assessed; a small set, and cytology rather than tumor tissue.
- 91Sun WW, Dong ZW, Zhou YM, et al. Improving the identification and diagnostic efficiency of Metagenomic Next-Generation Sequencing for mycobacterial granuloma on postoperative formalin-fixed paraffin-embedded specimens.doi:10.1016/j.micinf.2023.105185 · PMID 37453490
Broad sequencing of archived surgical granuloma blocks detected all 31 confirmed mycobacterial infections, with 88% specificity, and all 19 tuberculosis cases against 47% for the standard molecular test on the same blocks; mycobacteria, 65 cases.
- 92Sitthirak S, Wangwiwatsin A, Jusakul A, et al. Whole exome sequencing of multi-regions reveals tumor heterogeneity in Opisthorchis viverrini-associated cholangiocarcinoma.doi:10.1038/s41598-025-95142-3 · PMID 40157958
Multiregion sequencing of 52 samples from 13 liver-fluke-associated bile-duct cancers found marked genetic differences between regions of the same tumor; 13 patients, human mutations only.
- 93Baldwin DA, Feldman M, Alwine JC, Robertson ES. Metagenomic assay for identification of microbial pathogens in tumor tissues.doi:10.1128/mBio.01714-14 · PMID 25227467
Describes PathoChip, a microarray carrying probes for viruses, bacteria, fungi, parasites and helminths, and shows it working on formalin-fixed tumor tissue; a platform paper, with no count of parasites in tumors.
- 94Banerjee S, Tian T, Wei Z, et al. Microbial Signatures Associated with Oropharyngeal and Oral Squamous Cell Carcinomas.doi:10.1038/s41598-017-03466-6 · PMID 28642609
PathoChip signatures, parasite signatures among them, reported in oral and oropharyngeal cancers; one group, no independent replication, and a signature is not an organism seen in tissue.
- 95Banerjee S, Tian T, Wei Z, et al. The ovarian cancer oncobiome.doi:10.18632/oncotarget.16717 · PMID 28410234
PathoChip signatures of viruses, bacteria, fungi and parasites reported in ovarian cancers; the same group as the oral and breast reports, with small comparison sets.
- 96Banerjee S, Tian T, Wei Z, et al. Distinct Microbial Signatures Associated With Different Breast Cancer Types.doi:10.3389/fmicb.2018.00951 · PMID 29867857
PathoChip signatures, parasites among them, reported across four breast cancer types; the same group again, and published before the reanalyses that showed how contamination creates false microbial signals.
- 97Hara K, Yamasaki K, Tahara M, et al. Epidemiologic evaluation of pleurisy diagnosed by surgical pleural biopsy using data from a nationwide administrative database.doi:10.1111/1759-7714.14368 · PMID 35243795
In 1,699 Japanese patients with pleurisy diagnosed by surgical biopsy, lung fluke disease was 0.1%; an administrative database, so the diagnoses are coded, not reviewed.
- 98Machicado C, Marcos LA. Carcinogenesis associated with parasites other than Schistosoma, Opisthorchis and Clonorchis: A systematic review.doi:10.1002/ijc.30028 · PMID 26840624
Found parasites such as Echinococcus, Strongyloides and Fasciola inside cancers or tumors, but concluded cause and effect was not established; 19 studies from 1,266 screened.
This is education, not medical advice. Nothing on this page is written with knowledge of your history, your medications or your risks, and nothing here is a dose. Do not start or stop any treatment on the basis of it — talk to your own physician. Read the full medical disclaimer.